November 1, 2023 Dog Collar vs Harness: Pros & Cons

Dog Collar vs Harness: Pros & Cons

Which Collar vs Harness is Right for Your Canine Companion?


When it comes to walking your furry friend, one of the first decisions you need to make is whether to use a dog collar or a harness. Both options have their advantages and disadvantages, and it’s important to choose the right one for your canine companion. In this article, we’ll explore the pros and cons of dog collars and harnesses, helping you make an informed decision. 

Dog Collar 

A dog collar is a common choice for many dog owners. Here are the pros and cons of using a dog collar


Easy to use: Dog collars are straightforward to put on and take off. They usually feature a buckle or clip closure, making it quick and convenient to secure your dog. 

Identification and tags: Collars provide a convenient place to attach your dog’s identification tags, making it easier for others to identify your furry friend and contact you if they get lost. As an alternatively to an identification tag you can have the collar either embroidered or embossed with your contact details. 

Training tool: Collars can be used as training tools, especially for teaching your dog to walk on a leash. The gentle pressure on their neck can help discourage pulling and promote better leash manners. 


Strain on the neck: One of the main disadvantages of using a collar with a lead is the potential strain it can put on your dog’s neck. Dogs that pull excessively or jerk on the leash may experience discomfort or even injury to their neck and throat. 

Ineffective for certain breeds: Some breeds, such as brachycephalic (short-nosed) dogs or those with respiratory issues, may be better suited to using a harness. Collars can put unnecessary pressure on their delicate airways, leading to breathing difficulties. 

Increased risk of injury: Dogs that pull aggressively or lunge may be at a higher risk of neck injuries when wearing a collar. It’s essential to consider your dog’s behaviour and physical characteristics before opting for just a collar  

Dog Harness 

A harness offers an alternative way to walk your dog and distribute pressure more evenly across their body. Let’s look at the pros and cons of using a harness: 


Reduced strain on the neck: Unlike collars, harnesses distribute pressure more evenly across your dog’s chest and back. This can be especially beneficial for dogs with neck or throat issues, as well as those prone to pulling. 

Enhanced control: Harnesses provide better control over your dog’s movements, making it easier to guide them during walks. They are particularly useful for larger, stronger dogs or those still in training. You can buy harnesses with two points of lead attachment. Giving even greater control. 

Decreased risk of escape: Some dogs are experts at slipping out of their collars. Harnesses offer added security, minimizing the chances of your furry friend wriggling free. 


Difficulty in fitting: Some dogs may find it uncomfortable to wear a harness, especially if not fitted properly. It’s essential to choose a harness that is adjustable and fits snugly but not too tightly. 

Extra time to put on: Harnesses usually require more time to put on compared to collars, especially if they have various straps and buckles. If you’re always in a rush, this might be a consideration.  

Not suitable for all dogs: While harnesses are generally suitable for most dogs, some may find them restrictive or uncomfortable. It’s crucial to assess your dog’s behaviour and consult with a professional if needed. 


Choosing between a dog collar and a harness depends on various factors, including your dog’s breed, behaviour, and individual needs. If your dog walks calmly on a leash and doesn’t have any respiratory issues, a collar might suffice. However, if your furry friend pulls excessively or has specific health concerns, a harness could be a better option. Remember to always prioritise your dog’s comfort and well-being when making this decision. 

By understanding the pros and cons of both dog collars and harnesses, you can make an informed choice that ensures enjoyable and safe walks with your canine companion. So, evaluate your dog’s specific needs and preferences, consult with a professional if necessary, and find the right walking gear that suits your furry friend best. You may even find that using both are beneficial for your furry friend. Happy walking!